Learning Outcomes/Attributes
ABET e—An Ability to Identify, Formulate, and Solve Engineering Problems
|
Definitions |
knowledge |
comprehension |
Application |
analysis |
synthesis |
evaluation |
valuation |
|
Bloom’s Definition: |
Remembering previously learned information |
Grasping the meaning of information |
Applying knowledge to actual situations |
Breaking down objects or ideas into simpler parts and seeing how the parts relate and are organized |
Rearranging component ideas into a new whole |
Making judgments based on internal evidence or external criteria |
Sensitivity/willingness to receive (awareness w/o assessment, willingness to suspend judgment): Actively respond (comply, commit, internal satisfaction; Value (acceptance of worth, preference); Organize (when values conflict) |
|
Verbs |
Arrange, define, describe, duplicate, identify, label, list, match, memorize, name, order, outline, recognize, relate, recall, repeat, reproduce, select, state |
Classify, convert, defend, describe, discuss, distinguish, estimate, explain, express, extend, generalize, give example(s), identify, indicate, infer, locate, paraphrase, predict, recognize, rewrite, report, restate, review, select, summarize, translate |
Apply, change, choose, compute, demonstrate, discover, dramatize, employ, illustrate, interpret, manipulate, modify, operate, practice, predict, prepare, produce, relate, schedule, show, sketch, solve, use, write |
Analyze, appraise, break down, calculate, categorize, compare, contrast, criticize, diagram, differentiate, discriminate, distinguish, examine, experiment, identify, illustrate, infer, model, outline, point out, question, relate, select, separate, subdivide, test |
Arrange, assemble, categorize, collect, combine, comply, compose, construct, create, design, develop, devise, explain, formulate, generate, plan, prepare, propose, rearrange, reconstruct, relate, reorganize, revise, rewrite, set up, summarize, synthesize, tell, write |
Appraise, argue, assess, attach, choose, compare, conclude, contrast, defend, describe, discriminate, estimate, evaluate, explain, judge, justify, interpret, relate, predict, rate, select, summarize, support, value |
Accept, challenge, defend, respect, question, support, enjoy |
|
(1) Challenges the way things are being done |
Defines facts about current processes and procedures. |
Identifies and understands all problems associated with current methods. |
Uses knowledge to compute possible undesirable outcomes. |
Identifies and analyzes key areas where improvements can be made. |
Creates new alternatives by combining knowledge and information. |
Evaluate current practices to determine their efficiency and/or value. |
Uses personal value system to challenge methods used to solve engineering problems. |
|
(2) Improves on what has been done before |
Provides a list of possible alternatives. |
Recognizes the positive and negative aspects of each of the alternatives. |
Uses knowledge and information to change current processes and procedures. |
Can compare and contrast previous practices versus proposed improvements. |
Reconstructs current practices integrating improvements where needed. |
Appraises each alternative with respect to the others, including the option not to make a change. |
Uses knowledge and information to challenge past practices for continuous improvement. Actively seeks new opportunities, ideas, for continuous improvement. |
|
(3) Generates many potential solutions to a given problem |
Identifies and lists new alternatives to solve engineering problems. |
Describes and understands the engineering problem to be solved. |
Demonstrates ability and uses knowledge, information, and skills, to produce many alternatives to solve an engineering problem. |
Identifies and analyzes potential solutions to an engineering problem. |
Can create and explain potential solutions to an engineering problem. |
Uses judgement to evaluate the many alternatives to solve an engineering problem. |
Defends and supports potential solutions to solve an engineering problem. |
|
(4) Suggests new approaches to solving problems. |
Can identify the value of the perspectives of other people in relation to solving an engineering problem. |
Can describe new ideas in relation to how an engineering problem should be solved. |
Uses knowledge to compute possible new approaches. Generates innovative methods to solve problems. |
Examines new approaches to gain an understanding of which approach should be used to solve an engineering problem. |
Set-up a relation between an engineering problem and the new approaches developed to solve it. |
Can assess the effectiveness of each approach. |
Willingness to accept the perspectives of others as input when creating new approaches for solving engineering problems. |
|
(5) Discourages others from rushing to conclusions without facts. |
Lists the facts that the user can be certain of. Recognizes the importance of using facts to solve engineering problems. |
Understands and describes why facts are key to solving engineering problems. |
Uses facts to solve engineering problems and employs others to do the same. |
Separate facts from assumptions. |
Generates facts to support conclusions when solving engineering problems. |
Evaluates why decisions are made for validity. |
Motivates others to justify decision-making with information and data. Defends solving problems with facts. Challenges the reason behind the conclusion. |
|
(6) Handles unknowns or open-ended questions effectively. |
Defines what the user knows and does not know. |
Indicates where information is needed. |
Uses proper technique to answer questions that are unknown or open-ended. |
Asks questions to gain knowledge in areas that are unknown. |
Manages known information to formulate the answer to unknown and open-ended questions. |
Uses appropriate skills and techniques to estimate the answer to unknown and open-ended questions. |
Respects and accepts the impact of answering questions where the user does not have a sufficient knowledge base. |
|
(7) Demonstrates openness to new ideas. |
Can identify the value of the perspectives of other people's ideas in relation to solving an engineering problem. |
Recognizes the importance of receiving new ideas to solve engineering problems. |
Uses knowledge to demonstrate an openness to apply new ideas to solve engineering problems. |
Can compare and contrast new ideas versus existing ideas. |
Collects new idea information from multiple sources. |
Can assess the effectiveness of each new idea. Can judge new concepts fairly. |
Shows a willingness to use the perspective and ideas of others. Supports the generation of new ideas to solve an engineering problem. |
|
(8) Demonstrates the ability to apply theoretical concepts to practical problem solving. |
Can identify applicable theory and recognize past history when solving practical engineering problems. |
Can indicate how theory can be applied in practice. |
Can use theoretical concepts to develop solutions to solve practical engineering problems. |
Can breakdown theory concepts and analyze their relationship to solving practical engineering problems. |
Relates theoretical concepts to practical problem solving. |
Can interpret results using theoretical concepts as supporting evidence. |
Values and accepts the limitations of using theory concepts. Supports using theory to solve practical engineering problems. |
|
(9) Uses appropriate resources to locate pertinent information. |
Can recall appropriate resources to utilize to obtain information. |
Understands what resources to use to locate information for problem solving. |
Uses resources adequately to obtain information. Demonstrates knowledge of appropriate resources to use. |
Identifies and selects appropriate resources needed to gather information. |
Collects a list of resources to gather information necessary to solve the problem at hand. |
Appraises information resources needed to gather information. |
Can accept the quality and relevance of information from a source to gather information. |
|
(10) Estimates Outcomes. |
Can list and describe various outcomes for solving engineering problems. |
Can describe and defend alternatives to estimate outcomes. |
Applies knowledge of information and data with respect to alternatives to predict outcomes. |
Analyzes, and calculates outcomes to engineering problems. |
Collects possible outcomes to a given engineering problem. |
Can interpret the given information and predict possible outcomes. |
Can support and defend predicted outcomes. |
|
(11) Compares calculations to estimates to check for errors. |
Can recognize errors when comparing the estimate to the final calculation. |
Identifies calculation errors when comparing the estimate to the final calculation. |
Uses mathematical skills to discover errors associated with the estimate and the final calculation. |
Can compare results to estimates to identify errors. |
Relates calculation results to estimations to verify data. |
Can evaluate calculations to see if the solutions adhere to expected values/units. |
Questions calculations when comparing to estimates for support. |
|
(12) Develops criteria for the evaluation of proposed solutions. |
Can define and list key components that a proposed solution should consider. |
Can create and classify criteria used to evaluate proposed solutions. |
Demonstrates knowledge of engineering principles necessary for developing criteria. |
Can categorize information into criteria for the evaluation of proposed solutions. |
Construct a list of criteria that addresses the problem and for the solutions to adhere to. |
Can generate criteria necessary to make judgements about proposed solutions. |
Defend the ability of the criteria to represent key information to a proposed solution. |
|
(13) Constructs a problem statement. |
Can define and outline problem variables and information given, to construct a problem statement. |
Uses the principles and theories of engineering to clearly define a problem statement. |
Uses information and knowledge to construct a problem statement effective for problem solving. |
Can analyze the problem variables to develop a problem statement. |
Combine and relate problem variables into a problem statement. |
Selects information useful in constructing a problem statement. |
Challenge current situation to determine flaws that can be improved on. Support problem statement as to its ability to generate possible solutions in the key areas to improve the situation. |
|
(14) Generates ideas for possible solutions. |
Recalls on past experience as a foundation for identifying new ideas. |
Can create and describe new ideas to be used for solving engineering problems. |
Uses knowledge and information to produce many ideas for possible solutions to solve engineering problems. |
Can analyze and identify ideas that can be used to solve engineering problems. |
Generate a list of ideas that can contribute to possible problem solutions. |
Evaluate solutions on their ability to solve a given problem. |
Shows a willingness to use the perspective and ideas of others. Supports the generation of new ideas to solve an engineering problem. |
|
(15) Selects most appropriate solutions based on solution criteria. |
Can list all possible solutions and solution criteria. |
Can explain and select the "best" solution using a set of criteria. |
Uses knowledge, information and skills to select the "best" solution based on a set of criteria. |
Has the ability to compare and to contrast solutions to select the "best" based on a set of criteria. |
Assemble a collection of solutions that adhere to the given solution criteria. |
Chooses the "best" solution based on the solution criteria by using all of the evidence for support. |
Question solutions on how they adhere to the necessary criteria. |
|
(16) Selects and documents the solution to be recommended. |
Selects most appropriate solution based on criteria. |
Can explain and describe in writing the engineering problem solution. |
Demonstrates knowledge of the engineering problem to be solved. Can choose and write problem solution description. |
Can compare and contrast solutions to select the "best" solution. Can illustrate in writing the solution to be recommended. |
Prepare and write documentation that recommends and explains a solution. |
Uses facts when selecting solution to engineering problem. Provides detailed documentation of the recommended solution. |
Accept and support chosen solutions. |
|
(17) Collects feedback for continuous improvement. |
Ability to identify suitable sources of useful feedback. |
Recognizes the importance obtaining feedback from others for continuous improvement. |
Obtains and documents feedback of others for continuous improvement. |
Can analyze feedback to select the appropriate feedback that can be used for continuous improvement. |
Compose a list of positive feedback that can lead to future improvement. |
Evaluate feedback to determine if useful for future improvements. |
Respects both positive and negative feedback that contribute to further improvement. |
|
(18) Uses a basic knowledge of social sciences in the formulation of problem solutions. |
Relates social science knowledge when formulating an engineering problem solution. |
Has basic knowledge and understanding of the social sciences with respect to forming engineering problem solutions. |
Can apply social science knowledge when forming engineering problem solutions. |
Can relate the basic knowledge of social sciences to formulate engineering problem solutions. |
Relates social science knowledge to formulate engineering problem solutions. |
Justify problem solutions with knowledge of social sciences. |
Defends own background and knowledge in social sciences. |
|
(19) Applies basic knowledge of management to problem solving. |
Describes the responsibilities of management, and relates it to problem solving. |
Has basic knowledge of management techniques and applications. |
Can apply basic management knowledge towards solving engineering problems. |
Can relate the basic knowledge of management to solve engineering problems. |
Relates management knowledge to engineering problem solving. |
Appraise solutions from a managerial point of view. |
Defends own managerial skills and knowledge when solving problems. |
|
(20) Uses appropriate resources to locate pertinent information. |
Can define and describe resources needed to locate information. Can list where to find the resources and how they are used. |
Understands what resources to use to locate information for problem solving. |
Uses information and knowledge to construct a problem statement effective for problem solving. |
Identifies and selects appropriate resources needed to gather information. |
Collects a list of resources to gather information necessary to solve the problem at hand. |
Appraise information resources needed to gather information. |
The user can accept the quality and relevance of information from a source to gather information. |
|
(21) Estimates outcomes. |
Can list and describe various outcomes for solving engineering problems. |
Can describe and defend alternatives to estimate outcomes. |
Applies knowledge of information and data with respect to alternatives to predict outcomes. |
Analyzes, and calculates outcomes to engineering problems. |
Collects possible outcomes to a given engineering problem. |
Interpret the given information and predict possible outcomes. |
Support and defend predicted outcomes. |
|
(22) Compares calculations to estimates to check for errors. |
Can recognize errors when comparing the estimate to the final calculation. |
Identifies calculation errors when comparing the estimate to the final calculation. |
Uses mathematical skills to discover errors associated with the estimate and the final calculation. |
Can compare results to estimates to identify errors. |
Relates calculation results to estimations to verify data. |
Uses mathematical skills to discover errors associated with the estimate and the final calculation. |
Questions calculations when comparing to estimates for support. |
|
(23) Develops criteria for the evaluation of proposed solutions. |
Can define and list key components that a proposed solution should consider. |
Can create and classify criteria used to evaluate proposed solutions. |
Demonstrates knowledge of engineering principles necessary for developing criteria. |
Can categorize information into criteria for the evaluation of proposed solutions. |
Construct a list of criteria that addresses the problem and for the solutions to adhere to. |
Can generate criteria necessary to make judgements about proposed solutions. |
Defend the ability of the criteria to represent key information to a proposed solution. |
|
(24) Constructs models of physical systems, which incorporate those effects necessary to achieve the required accuracy by correctly estimating appropriate magnitudes for parameters and inputs. |
Can define methods of information gathering to acquire an accurate estimate. |
Can classify and identify useful methods of information gathering for the physical system model. |
Uses knowledge to construct models of physical systems. |
Analyze and examine individual components of the physical system and determine the appropriate accuracy needed. |
Generate a model of a physical system within an acceptable order of magnitude. |
Appraise the accuracy of the model against an actual physical system that it is simulating. |
Accept the determined orders of magnitude and accuracy to provide a model that simulates a physical system. |
|
(25) Applies the appropriate "conservation" principles of total mass, linear momentum, angular momentum, energy, and charge to model physical systems. |
Can relate principles of physics to engineering problem solving. |
Can predict the behavior of a system in terms of the physical properties of particles and energy. |
Uses knowledge of the principles of total mass, linear momentum, angular momentum, energy, and charge to model physical systems. |
Break down the physical system in terms of mass, linear momentum, angular momentum, energy and change. |
Explain the physical model as a whole, adhering to the basic principles of physics and conservation. |
Evaluate calculations to insure the laws of conservation are held. |
Question calculations to whether they adhere to the laws of conservation. |
|
(26) Applies the principles of the 2nd law of thermodynamics to predict upper bounds on the performance of thermodynamic cycles. |
Can relate the principles of the 2nd law of thermodynamics to engineering problem solving. |
Can estimate a physical system’s performance and efficiency with the second law of thermodynamics. |
Demonstrates and applies knowledge of the principles of the 2nd law of thermodynamics to predict upper bounds on the performance of thermodynamic cycles. |
Determine those components of the physical model that can be analyzed with the second law of thermodynamics. |
Explain the physical model as a whole to determine the upper bounds on performance of thermodynamic cycles, adhering to the second law of thermodynamics. |
Evaluate calculations to insure the second law of thermodynamics is held. |
Question calculations to whether they adhere to the second law of thermodynamics. |
|
(27) Judges, interprets, and explains the results of modeling by relating the results to the fundamental laws of physics. |
Can relate the results of the physical model to the fundamental laws of physics. |
Can summarize the results of a physical model and it’s relation to the fundamental laws of physics. |
Interpret the results of modeling in terms of the fundamental laws of physics. |
Identify the results of modeling that relate to the fundamental laws of physics. |
Summarize the results of physical modeling and the applicable principles of physics. |
Judges, interprets, and explains the results of modeling by relating the results to the fundamental laws of physics. |
Challenge and question a physical model in terms of its physical traits. |
|
(28) Applies the appropriate principles of chemistry to model engineering systems. |
Can relate the principles of chemistry to model engineering systems. |
Can explain the chemical properties of the engineering system model. |
Illustrate an engineering system using the principles of chemistry. |
Distinguish the applicable properties of chemistry to analyze the engineering system. |
Uses the principles of chemistry where appropriate to model engineering systems. |
Interpret the data from an engineering system and how it relates and adheres to the principles of chemistry. |
Question those areas where the laws of chemistry apply in an engineering system. |
|
(29) Makes appropriate and necessary chemical-related assumptions for parameters and inputs to enable models to provide the required accuracy. |
Can identify which assumptions can be made safely without damaging the integrity of the data. |
Can estimate the necessary chemical-related parameters and inputs for engineering system models. |
Uses knowledge of chemistry to make accurate assumptions. |
Analyze each parameter and input to the engineering system to determine the needed accuracy. |
Formulate a list of chemical-related assumptions to feed into the engineering system. |
Appraise each chemical-related assumption to yield the desired result. |
Question each assumption to check if it supports the engineering model. Support the chemical-related assumptions that have been made. |
|
(30) Applies the principles of chemistry to account for species mass in engineering systems. |
Relates the principles of chemistry to account for species mass in engineering systems. |
Can describe and explain species mass in engineering systems with chemical principles. |
Uses knowledge of chemistry to compute mass in engineering systems. |
Analyze species mass using the principles of chemistry in engineering systems. |
Combine the necessary principles of chemistry to analyze species mass in engineering systems. |
Describe species mass in an engineering system with the fundamental principles of chemistry. |
Accept or question species mass and its explanation or justification with the principles of chemistry. |
|
(31) Interprets and explains the results of modeling based on the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
Can relate the results of the physical model to the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
Can explain and report the details of the results of modeling based on the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
Applies knowledge of the fundamental laws of chemistry to analyze the results of the physical model. |
Contrast individual results from modeling to the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
Uses the fundamental laws of chemistry to support the evaluation of the results of modeling. |
Evaluate results of an engineering model and compares them to the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
Question the results of an engineering model and how they adhere to the fundamental laws of chemistry. |
|
(32) Demonstrates knowledge of the role of mathematics as a tool in modeling systems. |
Can relate the results of the physical model to mathematics. |
Can describe the relation between the physical model and the underlying mathematical principles. |
Uses mathematics knowledge as a tool when modeling systems. |
Relate the role of mathematics in modeling physical and engineering systems. |
Relate the role of mathematics in modeling engineering systems. |
Interpret an engineering model with mathematical theory and principles. |
Support an engineering system model with mathematical theory. |
|
(33) Demonstrates understanding of functional relationships. |
Can relate different mathematical functions to each other. |
Estimate the outcomes of functions based on the behavior of other functions. |
Can manipulate functions to solve for other relative functions. |
Examine the properties of functional relationships. |
Generates a series of relevant functions to an engineering model and relates them to one another. |
Interpret the meaning of the relationships between functions. |
Accept functional relationships where they occur in generating engineering models. |
|
(34) Distinguishes between change, rate of change, and integrals of functions. |
Can recall basic knowledge of calculus. |
Can classify change, rate of change and integrals of functions. Can describe the differences and similarities between each. |
Can compute and solve basic calculus problems. |
Distinguish the individual qualities and properties of change, rate of change and integrals. |
Formulate elementary principles of calculus in modeling engineering systems. |
Contrast the concepts of change, rate of change and integration from calculus. |
Accept and defend the individual roles change, rate of change and integration play in mathematics. |
|
(35) Constructs and solves a mathematical model that is appropriate for the accuracy required. |
Can state appropriate hypothesis and theorems to create mathematical models. |
Can explain the relevance of the hypothesis and theory to the mathematical model. |
Produce results from a mathematical model that has the needed accuracy. |
Can break down components of a mathematical model, and analyze each section independently. |
Can assemble and synthesize individual components to solve a mathematical model with accuracy. |
Appraise and evaluate the level of accuracy of a mathematical model. |
Defend and support or question and challenge a mathematical model’s level of accuracy. |
|
(36) Makes appropriate and necessary mathematics-related assumptions to enable models to provide the required accuracy. |
Can recall basic mathematical and statistical knowledge to support assumptions made to achieve accuracy. |
Understands the mathematics-related assumptions to enable models to provide the required accuracy. |
Use mathematical knowledge to make assumptions about an engineering model. |
Distinguish the needed levels of accuracy in the various areas of an engineering model. |
Construct and propose mathematical assumptions to generate the required accuracy. |
Assess and judge assumptions to see if they support the needed accuracy. |
Accept and support the mathematics-related assumptions generated. |
|
(37) Judges, interprets and explains the results of engineering systems that are due to the mathematics employed. |
Can define and describe the results of engineering systems by recalling mathematical knowledge. |
Can employ the mathematical knowledge needed and express how it relates to the engineering system. |
Interpret mathematical aspects of an engineering system’s results. |
Examine each of the results from an engineering system in terms of its mathematical properties. |
Summarize the results of engineering systems and the applicable principles of mathematics. |
Judges, interprets, and explains the results of modeling by relating the results to the principles of mathematics. |
Challenge and question a engineering model in terms of its mathematical traits. |